The S-Curve Rug, my first design in the 2015 Interweave Crochet Home edition. |
Dear Peak Media:
You are the “new” owner of many Interweave magazine titles,
including Interweave Knits and Interweave Crochet. Purchased from F+W Media as
a result of its early March, 2019 bankruptcy filing, you are also the owner of
the online communities and other intellectual property associated with the
titles. However, given that Terry O’Toole, the owner of Macanta Investments
(the money behind Peak Media), was the chairman of the Board of Directors of the
bankrupt F+W, Greg Osberg, the new CEO of Peak Media was the most recent (and
interim) CEO at F+W, the sole editor posting knitting design calls was a
former editor with an Interweave magazine title, and even Peak Media’s
contracts administrator is the former contracts administrator for Interweave
under F+W, I wonder, what, exactly, is new at Peak Media?
From your lack of clear communication with the design and
maker communities, to your focus on padding your own bottom line (the only two
avenues of electronic contact on Peak Media’s site are for advertising or media
inquiries), this seems like business as usual at an F+W Media property – you know,
the F+W that failed to listen to employees as it squandered millions in equity
funding and imploded – the one that the former chairman of the Board is now in control of the investment money here at Peak Media Properties, LLC. If I was unsure of the
exact posture of Peak Media, a recent email from you (addressed to “Dearest
Contributor,” which elicited a hearty, ironic laugh from this recipient) made
it abundantly clear: the communication stated it had good news – an expanded
version of a program, in which I have no control over my intellectual property,
and for which you provided absolutely no particulars, was in the works! Best of
all, I had less than two weeks to opt out
of all this good news. Wow. Insert so much additional hearty, ironic laughter right
there.
Now, as an independent designer with 7+ years of design
publishing (my own and with third parties), it would be easy for me to just let
all this sit right here and marinate. However, as a proud female small (ok,
micro!) business owner who has managed to survive the last almost eight years
designing in a medium - yarn and textiles - that I have loved since childhood, I
find it only fair to put out into the world how I might go about things in this
“new” version of the F+W legacy. So … well … here goes nothing:
1. Please let Peak Media Properties, LLC find its
humility muscle, like, yesterday.
2. Once it finds such muscle, let it be flexed in
the form of a DAMNED APOLOGY: to designers for squandering their good will and
stomping on their intellectual property without any respect, and to the maker
community at large for this lack of respect. I not-so-elegantly remind you that,
if not for the collective intellectual property of the independent design
community, there would be no publication foundation upon which Peak Media
Properties, LLC could build.
3. Please publish this DAMNED APOLOGY not only in
all of your publications, but also in your competitors’ publications. As I have
stated previously elsewhere, we all rise and fall together. What you are doing
right now, Peak Media, will have a ripple effect on the entire hand knit and
crochet industry which, at its zenith, was a large portion of the income bread and butter at F+W.
4. Going forward, please be transparent in all
communications with the design community. It is our intellectual property you
wish to leverage for your own gain at, if the past is any indication, our
direct expense. In case you were not aware, there is not one independent
designer I know that can earn a living wage designing solely for third party
publication. Not one. Yet, Peak Media personnel seem to be earning a living
wage doing just one job.
5. Sort of in tandem with #4, and on the eve of the
long U.S. Labor Day weekend, please pay a living wage for our designs, be
transparent about that wage, and provide greater flexibility in sharing intellectual
property rights with the independent design community. Interweave publishing
titles provide compensation at the mid-to-lower end for independent designs and
currently have some of the most restrictive intellectual property rights’
contract clauses in the industry.
At this point I sigh. When I first wrote about the bankruptcy, I was willing to keep an open mind, to see what would transpire, despite the fact that I am one of F+W's creditors (albeit a very small one - other designers were in for far more than me). I maintain that I, as an independent designer who
erroneously believed in the good of being published in an Interweave publication,
expected too little in the past. Not anymore.
Despite the above, Peak Media does have an incredible
opportunity right here, right now. Start to rebuild the trust and good will
that F+W eroded. It can be done. Don’t take a wait and see approach – seize the
day! Truly lead the Interweave publishing titles you purchased to a brighter
place where mutual respect might flourish instead of the muscular, opaque, and
lop-sided approach of the past. That, of course, will take a significant amount of public courage and a willingness to think and do things differently.
As the organizational posture currently stands, I will not be creating submissions for any
design calls issued by Peak Media titles. I genuinely need to see some deep, structural changes.
I am happily close to self-publishing my second soft-cover publication, have
third-party-published designs in the works, and consistently self-publish
single designs. I have a small core of makers with which I regularly make
garments and accessories, and to whom I am not only dedicated, but for whose
support I am supremely grateful. Nothing
would make me happier than to augment the former with future designs published in titles
run by a Peak Media that viewed me and my creativity as a respected partner and
equal, not merely a “dear contributor.”
Very truly yours -